Brussels: An entry ban on Russian combatants moved closer to the centre of EU sanctions policy this week, after High Representative Kaja Kallas said on 16 November that the measure could feature in the 22nd sanctions package. Speaking after the Foreign Affairs Council, she admitted that some member states still have question marks about implementation. She also suggested the necessary data would be quite easy to obtain, because Russia keeps digital records of its soldiers.
Moscow reacted within hours. Vyacheslav Volodin, speaker of the State Duma, accused Kallas of announcing a plan to steal personal data and claimed her remarks breached three articles of the Russian criminal code, carrying a combined sentence of around 20 years. The threat is theatrical, yet it shows how sensitive the Kremlin is to any step that follows its veterans beyond the battlefield.
The political appetite in Brussels is real. Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has said the 22nd package will reach member states before the European Council of 26 and 27 November, and foreign ministers on Monday also called for a tougher visa policy towards Russia. Estonia already applies a national entry ban on Russian combatants, Lithuania is preparing its own, and eight governments from the Baltic states to Germany and Romania have pressed Brussels for an EU-wide answer. Their joint letter warned that more than 180,000 Russian soldiers had criminal convictions before Moscow released them early in exchange for military contracts.
The harder question is technical and legal. Ukraine has shared the identities of more than half a million Russian soldiers, according to a Euronews investigation published on 6 November, yet member states have entered fewer than 1% of those names into the Schengen Information System. Each alert requires an individual assessment showing that the person threatens public policy or security, and a raw list from a belligerent does not meet that test on its own. That leaves any entry ban on Russian combatants resting on a thin evidential base, and some of the people named may no longer be alive.
Intelligence alone cannot carry an entry ban on Russian combatants. Kallas is right that the information exists, but data gathered through covert channels would struggle in national courts and at the Court of Justice in Luxembourg, where any refused traveller could challenge an alert. A sanctions listing built on weak evidence would hand Moscow a propaganda victory and expose the Union to annulment rulings.
The more durable route lies in the Schengen rulebook itself. Officials have discussed amending the Schengen Borders Code so that states can restrict a defined category of people who pose a security threat, alongside a Visa Code revision the Commission is expected to propose in early 2027. Such a reform would make an entry ban on Russian combatants enforceable without thousands of separate dossiers. A Commission paper has also floated requiring military booklets from Russian men of conscription age as supporting visa documents, although diplomats fear forged papers and false identities.
Divisions persist. Italy, France and Spain issue a large share of Schengen visas to Russians, and Rome in particular cites consular overload and legal risk. The July sanctions package already made the entry ban on Russian combatants conditional on implementing measures after Italian and French resistance. The attempted drone attack on Leipzig airport in August, which Berlin attributed to Moscow, involved a Belarusian suspect holding a tourist visa from the Italian consulate in Minsk, a reminder that one weak consulate weakens the whole area.
For the 2026 sanctions cycle, the test is whether ministers can turn a slogan into an enforceable rule. A credible entry ban on Russian combatants will need clear legal criteria, shared risk assessments and a common data standard, not just political will. If the 22nd package delivers that framework, Europe will have built a lasting shield for its borders, and if it does not, Volodin’s threats may be the loudest result of the debate.





