Luxembourg: The Article 255 panel, the expert body that vets every nominee for the EU’s two highest courts, judged nine candidates unsuitable over the four years to 28 February 2026, according to its eighth activity report. The Council of the EU published the report on 17 November 2026, giving governments and MEPs a rare look at how Europe chooses its judges.
The report covers the period from 1 March 2022 to 28 February 2026. During that time the Article 255 panel delivered 70 opinions on candidates for posts as judges and advocates-general at the Court of Justice and the General Court. Thirty-three of those opinions concerned people seeking a first term, and the nine unfavourable verdicts all fell within that group.
That works out at roughly one in four first-time nominees failing the test, a striking ratio for candidates that national governments put forward. According to the summary of the report, member states then followed the Article 255 panel’s advice in every case. No government pushed through a nominee after a negative opinion during the four-year period.
The Council announcement of the eighth activity report places the document in a long series that began after the Lisbon Treaty. Article 255 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union created the body to give an opinion on candidates’ suitability before member states appoint them by common accord.
Seven senior lawyers sit on the Article 255 panel. Former Court of Justice judge Allan Rosas chairs it, and the members include former Court of Justice president Vassilios Skouris and former Irish chief justice Frank Clarke. A secretariat inside the Council’s General Secretariat supports their work, which combines written scrutiny with closed hearings for first-time candidates.
The Article 255 panel tests nominees against criteria that flow from the Treaties. It looks at legal ability, professional experience and the capacity to perform judicial duties independently. It also weighs language skills, the ability to work in a multilingual team, and guarantees of independence, impartiality, probity and integrity.
The timing gives the report extra weight. Rule of law disputes increasingly land in Luxembourg, from judicial independence cases against Poland and Hungary onward. Each ruling depends on the authority of the judges who sign it, and a credible filter at the entry point protects that authority.
Critics have long argued that national selection procedures remain uneven, with some capitals running open competitions and others relying on government choice. The Article 255 panel cannot rewrite those procedures, yet its opinions push weaker systems to raise their standards. A rejected nominee is an embarrassment few governments wish to repeat.
For candidates, the message from the report is plain: the hearing is not a formality. For governments, the Article 255 panel has become a quiet but effective check on patronage, and its eighth report shows the filter still bites as the Court of Justice and the General Court prepare for further partial renewals.





