Aleja Szucha: The fight over the Polish Constitutional Tribunal deepened in early November 2026, as Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek defended the court’s newly elected judges and said he was open to possible EU mediation. Żurek spoke to journalists in Warsaw on 5 November, days after a dramatic night at the tribunal building.
The dispute pits Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s government against President Karol Nawrocki. In March, the Sejm appointed six new judges. Only two of them took the oath before Nawrocki. The other four swore their oath at a ceremony in parliament on 9 April, without the president. Two more judges have been elected since, bringing the total to eight.
According to the justice ministry, tribunal president Bogdan Święczkowski has blocked five of those eight judges from taking their seats. The government says the oath sworn in parliament is valid, while the president’s camp rejects that reading of the constitution.
International bodies have weighed in. In May, the European Court of Human Rights asked Polish authorities not to obstruct the judges. In October, the Venice Commission said an alternative oath procedure was possible, which the government reads as support for its position.
The quarrel matters well beyond Poland. The Polish Constitutional Tribunal rules on whether national laws conform with the constitution, and its legitimacy has been contested since 2015, when the previous government reshaped its bench. The Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights both questioned rulings by the Polish Constitutional Tribunal in later years, and restoring trust in the court has been a central promise of the Tusk government.
Events at the Polish Constitutional Tribunal escalated at the end of October. On 30 October, Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska suspended Święczkowski and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański. On the night of 30 to 31 October, Nawrocki entered the building of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal. The ministry says he forced his way past Korwin-Piotrowska.
Police were stationed around the tribunal during the crisis. Żurek said officers were there to protect judges from demonstrators. The opposition accused the police of helping what it called a takeover of the court. On 3 November, the eight new judges held a general meeting, with a disputed quorum, and adopted the tribunal’s draft budget for 2027.
On the EU side, Żurek said he had not requested mediation and that none had been offered. He added that he remains open to the possibility. He keeps in regular contact with Justice Commissioner Michael McGrath and European Parliament President Roberta Metsola, and the Commission has followed Polish rule of law reforms closely since the change of government.
Commission President Ursula von der Leyen reportedly skipped a press conference at a Visegrád Group summit that Nawrocki attended, a move widely read as a gesture of support for Tusk. Tusk insists the legal question is settled and says he wants to persuade the president to de-escalate.
No date for mediation has been set, and the standoff now touches budget planning as well as judicial appointments. Until the government and the president agree on who sits on the bench, the Polish Constitutional Tribunal will remain a test of whether Warsaw can restore full judicial legitimacy under EU rule of law standards.





